THE HONEST TRUTH ABOUT STARTUP IDEAS
You’ve had it for six months. Maybe longer. It hits you in the shower. It wakes you up at 2 AM. You tell your friends about it (they nod politely). You’ve already mentally quit your job three times.
The idea feels inevitable. Like someone should have thought of it already. Like YOU should already be working on it full-time.
Here’s what founders don’t tell you: 67% of startup ideas fail not because they’re hard to build, but because nobody actually wants them.
Let that sink in. Not 10%. Not 30%. 67%.
You can have the perfect product, beautiful design, and flawless execution. But if you’re building something the market doesn’t desperately need? You’re building a very expensive hobby.
The good news? You can find out if your idea is real in just two weeks. No code. No funding. No risk. Just validation.
This is the framework founders like Rahul (built a $2M ARR SaaS company) and Priya (7-figure D2C brand) used BEFORE they quit their jobs. And it’s the framework we’re going to walk through together.
WHAT IS “STARTUP IDEA VALIDATION”? (LET’S DEFINE IT)
Before we go deeper, let’s be clear on what validation means.
Validation ≠ people saying they like your idea
Validation = people willing to pay for it. Actually. With money. Not hypothetically.
See the difference?
Your mom saying “that’s a great idea, beta” is not validation. Your mom pre-ordering your product is validation (even if she feels obligated).
Real validation looks like:
- Someone says “I have this exact problem”
- You describe your solution
- They say “How much? I’ll take it”
- They pull out their wallet (or credit card)
That’s it. That’s the bar.
Now, let’s talk about how to actually find it.
THE 3-STEP VALIDATION FRAMEWORK (THAT ACTUALLY WORKS)
STEP 1: TALK TO 20 PEOPLE (2 WEEKS)
This is the foundation. Everything else builds on this.
What you’re doing: Structured interviews with 20 people in your target market. Not casual coffee chats. Not pitches. Interviews.
Why 20?
- After 10 interviews, you’ll see patterns
- After 20 interviews, those patterns are reliable
- Statistically, if 50%+ say they’d pay, you’re onto something
How to find these 20 people:
-
LinkedIn (if B2B)
- Search for job titles of your target customer
- DM 30 people, you’ll get ~15-20 responses
- Book 20-minute calls
-
Founder communities (if B2C)
- Reddit (r/IndieHackers, relevant niches)
- Facebook groups
- Online communities
- Your existing network
-
Industry events
- Attend 1-2 events in your space
- Talk to 10-15 people in person
What to ask (The 5 Perfect Questions):
-
“What’s your biggest pain point in [industry/area]?”
Listen. Don’t interrupt. Let them vent.
-
“How are you currently solving this?”
Understand their workaround. There’s always a workaround.
-
“How much would you pay to solve this permanently?”
They’ll tell you the real number (or say “not much” = red flag)
-
“Would you use something like [your solution] to solve it?”
This is the key question. Listen for hesitation.
-
“If we built this, would you be interested in being an early user?”
This tells you if they’re genuinely interested or just being polite
Pro Tips:
- Record these calls (with permission). Listen again later. You’ll hear nuances you missed.
- Take notes in a shared document. You’ll see patterns emerge by interview #10.
- Ask “why?” after every answer. Dig deeper.
What you’re looking for:
- Do 50%+ of people describe the same problem?
- Do 50%+ say they’d be willing to pay?
- Do they ask follow-up questions about your solution?
If yes to all three = Signal of real demand.
STEP 2: BUILD YOUR “FAKE MVP” (1 WEEK)
Now here’s where most founders mess up.
They say “I need to build the product to validate.”
No. You don’t.
MVP = Minimum Viable Product (the real definition)
A real but basic version of your product that you can test with users.
Fake MVP (what we recommend)
A manual, fake version that proves the concept without code.
Examples:
-
If you’re building a scheduling SaaS:
- Create a Google Form
- Collect data from customers
- You manually schedule them in their calendars
- Do this for 5 customers
- If they keep paying, you build the product
-
If you’re building an e-commerce app:
- Build a Shopify store
- Run Facebook ads
- Collect sales
- See if people actually buy
- Measure conversion rate, repeat purchase rate
-
If you’re building a done-for-you service:
- Launch on Fiverr or Upwork
- Offer the service manually
- Get reviews and testimonials
- Understand what customers actually want
- Then scale
Why this works:
- You’ll learn customer pain points (the real ones, not theoretical)
- You’ll understand unit economics (cost to acquire, cost to serve)
- You’ll build an email list of actual interested people
- You’ll have real testimonials
- If nobody bites, you haven’t wasted 6 months
Tools for Fake MVPs (No-Code):
- Landing page: Webflow, Carrd, Framer
- Scheduling: Calendly, Acuity Scheduling
- E-commerce: Shopify, WooCommerce
- Forms: Typeform, Google Forms, Jotform
- CRM: Airtable, Notion
- Automation: Zapier, Make.com
STEP 3: MEASURE 3 CRITICAL METRICS (WEEK 2)
Now you’re running your Fake MVP. People are signing up/buying/requesting.
What do you measure?
Metric #1: Conversion Rate
- How many people see your offer?
- How many say “yes”?
- Target: 10%+ is strong
- (Example: 100 people see your landing page, 12 sign up = 12% conversion = Good signal)
Metric #2: Willingness to Pay
- Out of 100 users, how many would actually pay?
- Target: 20%+ is strong
- (Example: You have 50 signups. You ask 5 people “Would you pay ₹5K/month?” If 2 say yes = 40% = Very strong)
Metric #3: Retention/Repeat Usage
- Week 1: 100 people sign up
- Week 2: 40 people are still using it (40% retention)
- Target: 40%+ week 2 retention is strong
- (If everyone leaves after trying it once = you’re not solving a real problem)
Red Flags (Kill the Idea If You See These):
- Conversion rate below 5%
- Nobody willing to pay more than “small amount”
- 70%+ churn in week 2
- Customers asking for features, not the core product
REAL CASE STUDY: RAHUL’S VALIDATION (B2B SaaS)
The Idea:
SaaS tool for Indian CA firms to automate tax compliance. Rahul thought it was genius.
Week 1: The Interviews
- Interviewed 20 CAs
- 18 said they had the pain
- 15 said they’d pay ₹8,000-12,000/month
- 12 asked “When can I try it?”
Strong signal. Rahul had demand.
Week 2: Fake MVP
- Created a Zapier workflow that automated 80% of the work
- Manually did the remaining 20% for first 3 clients
- Charged them [translate:₹3,000/month] to try
Result:
- 3 signed up
- All 3 were still using after 2 weeks
- All 3 asked “Can I refer a friend?”
Week 3: The Decision
- Real demand validated ✓
- Customers willing to pay ✓
- Retention looking good ✓
Rahul quit his job. He’s now at $2M ARR.
Compare this to Priya, who built for 6 months without talking to customers. Got 2 signups. Still has her day job.
THE “VALIDATION DOCUMENT” (YOUR PROOF)
After you’ve done these 3 steps, you have a document that changes everything:
What you write:
- Problem identified: “CAs spend 20 hours/week on compliance. They hate it.”
- Market size: “50,000 CAs in India. If even 1% pays [translate:₹10K/month] = [translate:₹50Cr] TAM”
- Validation evidence: “20 interviews, 15 said they’d pay. 3 used our MVP. 100% retention in week 2.”
- Customer testimonials: “This saved me 15 hours/week” – CA, Delhi
- Next steps: “Building full product. Beta users ready.”
This document is GOLD because:
- It impresses investors (you’ve de-risked)
- It aligns your team (everyone believes in the problem)
- It guides your product roadmap (build what customers want, not what you think)
- It gives you confidence (you’re building something real)
COMMON MISTAKES FOUNDERS MAKE (AVOID THESE)
Mistake #1: “My friends said it’s a great idea”
Your friends love you. They’re not objective.
Validate with strangers. People outside your network.
Mistake #2: “People said it’s helpful, so they’ll pay”
Helpful ≠ willing to pay
You need to see money exchange hands.
Mistake #3: “I’m so convinced, I don’t need validation”
Your conviction doesn’t matter. The market does.
Some of the best ideas (Snapchat, Instagram) had weak early signals.
Validation keeps you honest.
Mistake #4: “Validation means I’m done researching”
No. This is continuous.
Talk to customers weekly, even after launch.
The market changes. Stay close to it.
YOUR ACTION PLAN (THIS WEEK)
Monday:
- Write down your startup idea in 1 sentence
- List the 20 ideal customers (who have the pain)
- Find 5 of them on LinkedIn
Tuesday-Thursday:
- Schedule 20 calls (15 mins each)
- Ask the 5 perfect questions
- Document everything in a Google Sheet
Friday:
- Tally your results
- If 50%+ say they’d pay: Move to Fake MVP
- If less than 50%: Consider pivoting or killing
Week 2:
- Build your Fake MVP (1-2 days, max)
- Launch to your 20 interviewees
- Measure the 3 metrics
- Write your validation document
Total time investment: 1-2 weeks
Total money invested: [translate:₹0-5,000]
Risk: Minimal
THE BOTTOM LINE
You’re standing at a fork in the road.
Path A: Quit your job, spend 6 months building, raise money (if you can), launch to crickets. Realize you built something nobody wants.
Path B: Spend 2 weeks validating. Get proof that real people want this. THEN quit your job with confidence.
Path B founders are 5x more likely to succeed.
Which path are you taking?
NEXT IN THIS SERIES
Next week we’ll dive into:
Have questions about validation? Drop them in the comments. We read every one.
RECOMMENDED RESOURCES
Books:
- “The Lean Startup” by Eric Ries (free chapter on validation)
- “The Mom Test” by Rob Fitzpatrick (How to talk to customers)
Tools for your Fake MVP:
- Carrd – Landing pages
- Zapier – Workflow automation
- Typeform – Surveys
- Calendly – Scheduling
- Airtable – Database
Communities for finding interviewees:
- r/IndieHackers – Startup community
- Saastr Community – For B2B founders
- Startup communities in your city
Further Reading:
